Re: Alan Ladd
Posted: July 16th, 2011, 8:38 pm
Well, I saw it. Now I must say I've never read the book guys; and the preconceived notions I might have had having seen Robert Redford's version back in '74 are all but disappeared deep inside the cortex of my brain. (Very little plot memory. Just remember the clothes and the colors). Alan Ladd does a wonderful job as Jay. Poor sod. Stuck with the dream of a girl that I don't think he ever REALLY knew. Our "Laddie" boy definitely had the demeanor of some nouveau riche guy thinking that these 'things' and people he bought would get him into the upper echelons of society. Or maybe he knew it wouldn't get him in, but he did it all to be in the circle...the sphere that Daisy traveled in. I believe him. I believe him all the way. (I didn't believe it was the 20's.) His longing and seeking approval by her I totally believed...especially when he showed her his wardrobe. Like a kid showing off his new shiny red firetruck.
I've made my dislike of Blandy Sullivan known before but I have to say I enjoyed him in this movie. Shelley was a shrieking mad woman comin' down those stairs after DaSilva. At first I thought she was Judy Holliday barreling down those stairs. I saw some shockingly graphic things for 1949 that made me audibly go "Whoa!!!" But I won't spoil what they are. Ruth Hussey. I don't know...she didn't bother me one way or the other as Jordan, but I totally see what you mean Miss G., when you say she breaks character to do this narration. I didn't quite believe the romance between her and MacDonald Carey. I don't know WHOSE fault that was but since he's not one of my favorites, why don't I just blame him.
Poor Jay (Ladd). To trust Daisy...to pin his hopes and dreams of a happily ever after with her. Betty Field's voice was just too tremulous for me. I felt unnerved by it. Casting suggestions of Maureen O'Sullivan and Yvette Mimieux are excellent!!! Yvette, darn I keep forgetting about her. She had her place in 1960's movies, didn't she. I would trust you guys with casting decisions before any mogul with a suit, a couch and a big fat ceegar. Again, as for Betty...she sure can play "breakdown" better'n anyone. When she was saying she couldn't face prison, that was the first comfortable moment I had with her.
I have two college movie buddies who I'll send over to YouTube to see this "lost" classic. I'm glad I did. My appreciation for Alan Ladd has increased tremendously. His height and his choice of roles (thanks Sue Carol) stumped him from being a bigger star than he was. By the time of "THE CARPETBAGGERS"...I dunno. (Say, could George Peppard have played Gatsby? He was beautiful enough. He certainly was cynical enough. Could he have been dreaming of Daisy for a decade?)
[youtube][/youtube]
P.S. Moira...I wrote this early this morning over at the "other" place. It's now 9:36PM (NY time) when I'm reading this discussion here at the Oasis and I'm just seeing your comments on George Peppard. Guess he won't be cast in the fantasy version of "...Gatsby."
I've made my dislike of Blandy Sullivan known before but I have to say I enjoyed him in this movie. Shelley was a shrieking mad woman comin' down those stairs after DaSilva. At first I thought she was Judy Holliday barreling down those stairs. I saw some shockingly graphic things for 1949 that made me audibly go "Whoa!!!" But I won't spoil what they are. Ruth Hussey. I don't know...she didn't bother me one way or the other as Jordan, but I totally see what you mean Miss G., when you say she breaks character to do this narration. I didn't quite believe the romance between her and MacDonald Carey. I don't know WHOSE fault that was but since he's not one of my favorites, why don't I just blame him.
Poor Jay (Ladd). To trust Daisy...to pin his hopes and dreams of a happily ever after with her. Betty Field's voice was just too tremulous for me. I felt unnerved by it. Casting suggestions of Maureen O'Sullivan and Yvette Mimieux are excellent!!! Yvette, darn I keep forgetting about her. She had her place in 1960's movies, didn't she. I would trust you guys with casting decisions before any mogul with a suit, a couch and a big fat ceegar. Again, as for Betty...she sure can play "breakdown" better'n anyone. When she was saying she couldn't face prison, that was the first comfortable moment I had with her.
I have two college movie buddies who I'll send over to YouTube to see this "lost" classic. I'm glad I did. My appreciation for Alan Ladd has increased tremendously. His height and his choice of roles (thanks Sue Carol) stumped him from being a bigger star than he was. By the time of "THE CARPETBAGGERS"...I dunno. (Say, could George Peppard have played Gatsby? He was beautiful enough. He certainly was cynical enough. Could he have been dreaming of Daisy for a decade?)
[youtube][/youtube]
P.S. Moira...I wrote this early this morning over at the "other" place. It's now 9:36PM (NY time) when I'm reading this discussion here at the Oasis and I'm just seeing your comments on George Peppard. Guess he won't be cast in the fantasy version of "...Gatsby."