I watched these recent films on dvd in the last week:
La Vie En Rose (2006): this French film about the life of Edith Piaf features a spectacular turn by
Marion Cotillard as the singer, whose life was as melodramatic as any song she ever sang. The songs and Piaf's singing (which is perfectly reproduced here, not imitated by another singer), are powerful, even if a person can't understand every word of French. While the bare facts of Piaf's family background were grim enough, (her mother and she lived on the streets while her soldier father fought in the French army & she was periodically dropped off at her grandmother's bordello for safekeeping), the film doesn't touch on World War II, Piaf's relationship with intellectuals such as Cocteau is ignored, as is Piaf's role in the French Resistance, her affairs and mentorship of several young men, including, among others, Yves Montand. Nor does it explain much about her mercurial temperament, though it presents her instability vividly, surely, this lady must've had enormous self-discipline to have gone as far as she did? Still, despite these quibbles, Cotillard is a remarkable actress, and the visual depiction of Piaf's whirlwind life was easy to get caught up in and the sequences when she sings are beautifully staged.
Venus (2006): This film is about an impossible flirtation between a very old, decrepit British character actor (
Peter O'Toole, who has looked as though he was "death warmed over" for about 30 years now) and a young, unschooled girl from the North of England (Jodie Whitaker, who is very touching). There is enough material here for about three movies. Here are just a few themes:
1.)It is an attempt to tell a new version of Pygmalion with some pathetic sexuality thrown in without any hope of fulfillment for either party.
2.)A story of the friendships among
O'Toole and his mates, among whom are his ex-wife, played wonderfully by
Vanessa Redgrave. The scenes between Redgrave and O'Toole are the most touching in the film for me. Another, central figure in this movie is a very familiar face from English movies of the last 70 years,
Leslie Phillips, who almost steals the movie. Mr. Phillips, who can be spotted in such early films as The Citadel (1938), the Doctor in the House series from the '50s and present day movies such as the Harry Potter flicks, is very funny, sad and outraged by life in general, though he proves to be a true friend to O'Toole and probably gives the young girl in the movie the only chance she'll ever have to have a life.
3.) The winding down of a life, as O'Toole clings to the remnants of this moderately successful actor. O'Toole's character is shown appearing in British soap operas as---not surprisingly--a corpse with the occasional Restoration play thrown in. The indignities and inanities and bravery of his efforts to keep going give Peter O'Toole some very funny and sad moments to enact. This is moving toward the end of the film, when a character reading the newspaper comes across a startlingly handsome photo of a young O'Toole.
As one character murmurs, appreciatively, "Coo, he was beautiful." Amen to that. I wouldn't recommend this movie to anyone who's squeamish about bodily functions, the ruder aspects of modern life or British humor, but I would think that people might enjoy it if they like good actors given a chance to play interesting, flawed human beings.
![Image](http://www.geocities.com/a_and_a2/phillipsotoole.JPG)
A game Peter O'Toole and Leslie Phillips at the opening of this movie in 2006.