Best And Worst Fathers In Film

[Detective Jim McLeod]

Happy Father's Day. Who do you think was the best and worst father in a film? This is what I think-

BEST

Gregory Peck in To Kill A Mockingbird (1962)

WORST

John Huston in Chinatown (1974)

[Sepiatone]

Too many choices to make, but you could get a "best" and "worst" from the same movie.

Gregory Peck in To Kill A Mockingbird (1962) for "best"

And......
James Anderson(Bob Ewell) in To Kill A Mockingbird(1962) for "worst"



Sepiatone

[Intrepid37]

Best: Tom Cruise in War of the Worlds

Worst: Christopher Walken in At Close Range

[Feinberg]

Gregory Peck in The Yearling

James Mason in Bigger Than Life

[Dargo]

Best: Fredric March in 'The Best Years of Our Lives' (...and presenting a good father, foibles and all, and without the role being idealized in any way)

Worst: James Coburn in 'Affliction' (...as mean and ornery as you'll ever see a father being depicted)

(...and both coincidentally being Academy Award winners for their performances)

[Swithin]

All from 1942:

Best: Paul Henreid in Now, Voyager

Worst: Claude Rains and Charles Coburn, both in Kings Row

[Belle]

Best: Brian Aherne, "My Son, My Son"
Worst: Christopher Walken, "Catch Me if You Can"

[Detective Jim McLeod]

Here's a couple more, maybe this can catch up to the mothers thread.

BEST
Cary Grant in Room For One More (1952)

WORST
Arthur Kennedy in Peyton Place (1957)

[LostHorizons]

Best: The Burning Bush (God) in the Prince of Egypt

No one can outdo God as father


Worst: Jean Marais in Donkey Skin- tried to rape his own daughter. Ick

[Intrepid37]

No one can outdo God as father

As Homer Simpson put it :

"God? He's always happy......no, wait....He's always mad!"